Following concerns raised by constituents across Chesterfield about the proposed Stagecoach service changes from 25 October, I met with John Young, Commercial Director at Stagecoach Yorkshire, to discuss the situation and what more can be done to protect local bus services.
Whilst bus passenger numbers have continued to fall across the UK and in the Chesterfield area particularly, it is hugely disappointing for bus passengers in the areas affected.
The proposed changes will have a real impact on people who rely on buses to get to work, school, healthcare appointments, shops and other essential services. The East Midlands Combined County Authority is looking at measures to mitigate the changes, but has acknowledged that these will not fully replace the routes, frequency or coverage being withdrawn.
The Authority announced last week that they are exploring a new bus service to help address some of the gaps created by changes to Services 74/74A and 90/90A. I have requested a meeting with Claire Ward, Mayor of the East Midlands, to discuss urgently what action can be taken to protect services and mitigate the proposed cuts. The Mayor has said that EMCCA is continuing to work with operators to explore further solutions, including options around Staveley, so I want to make sure the concerns of Chesterfield constituents are fully understood.
In my meeting with Mr Young, we discussed the specific challenges facing providers in Derbyshire and across the country, particularly outside cities. Bus usage is down 9% in Chesterfield, since 2024, a bigger decrease than anywhere else in the wider South Yorkshire/ North Midlands area. Bus passengers need reliable and regular services that enable them to get where they want in a reasonable time. If bus services are unreliable, then those passengers that can make alternative arrangements, but passenger reductions makes services unviable so it is a viscous circle in our area at the moment.
Whilst the company says that changing lifestyles, including increased online shopping, alongside the wider cost pressures facing households and businesses, have affected passenger numbers, specifically in Chesterfield the drop off has been more noticeable. Compared with some of the cities where bus usage has held up, Chesterfield has accessible and affordable parking and a reasonable road network, whilst it doesn’t have much bus lane provision and the excessive number of roadworks have affected timeliness pushing more passengers to find alternative methods of travel.
The reliability of the fleet and driver recruitment have both improved, but these changes partly reflect the slower services possible as a result of the amount of time that buses are waiting in roadworks and traffic jams,
Stagecoach has experienced significant delays to some services because of poorly managed or lengthy roadworks. When buses are repeatedly delayed, passengers understandably lose confidence in the service, which can then contribute to falling passenger numbers.
I will therefore be writing to Derbyshire County Council to ask what more can be done to improve the management of roadworks affecting bus routes. This should include looking at whether there can be greater provision for buses to get through roadworks, minimising unnecessary use of temporary traffic lights, and ensuring that multiple sets of roadworks are not allowed to cause repeated disruption along the same bus route wherever this can reasonably be avoided.
The Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, has also made improving public transport a priority and has already announced that single fares across England (outside London) will be reduced to £2 throughout all of 2027 and that the government is expanding free bus travel concessions for disabled passengers. Hopefully, if we combine these actions from central government with better vehicles, more drivers, less roadworks and congestion, and more reliability, it will boost the number of people using buses and make services more viable.
I will continue working with Stagecoach, the East Midlands Mayor, EMCCA, Derbyshire County Council and other bus operators to protect routes and services wherever possible.
Good public transport is not a luxury for many people. It is a lifeline without which they cannot get to work, education, healthcare and stay active in their community.